Baking is an art in itself, and the key to perfect baking lies in the right choice of cookware. The cookie sheet is one of the most important tools in your baking arsenal, and choosing the right one can be overwhelming. With so many types and brands available in the market, it can be a daunting task to find the perfect fit for your kitchen. But don’t worry, we’ve got you covered! We’ve researched and tested a wide range of cookie sheets to bring you our top-rated cookware picks.
Top-Rated Cookware Picks
There are a few key factors to consider when choosing a cookie sheet. The material, size, and thickness are all important features that can greatly impact your baking results. We’ve tested dozens of cookie sheets and have found our top-rated picks to be the ones that meet all of these criteria.
Our Favorite Cookware: Ree's Top Pick
First on our list is Ree’s top pick, the Nordic Ware Natural Aluminum Commercial Baker’s Half Sheet. Made of pure aluminum, this sheet has a natural nonstick surface that prevents food from sticking and cooks your cookies evenly. The aluminum also ensures that the sheet heats up quickly and maintains a consistent temperature, giving you perfect cookies every time.
Best Overall Cookware for Every Kitchen
If you’re looking for a versatile cookie sheet that works well with all types of baked goods, the USA Pan Aluminized Steel Cookie Sheet is the perfect fit. Made in the USA, this sheet is made of heavy-duty aluminized steel and has a silicone coating that provides a non-stick surface. The corrugated design also ensures that your cookies cook evenly and releases easily from the sheet.
Nonstick Cookware That Will Change Your Cooking Game
If you’re someone who’s always struggled with cookies sticking to the sheet, a nonstick option might be best for you. The Circulon Nonstick Bakeware Cookie Pan has a raised circle design that allows for better air circulation and even cooking. The nonstick surface makes it easy to remove your cookies and also helps with easy cleaning.
Textured Cookware That Will Elevate Your Dishes
A textured cookie sheet may not be a conventional choice, but it’s a great option for those who want to add some extra flair to their baked goods. The Wilton Perfect Results Premium Non-Stick Bakeware Large Cookie Pan has a beautiful diamond pattern that not only looks great but also helps with airflow and even cooking.
Colorful Cookware That Will Brighten Up Your Kitchen
Who says cookware has to be boring? The Rachael Ray Oven Lovin’ Non-Stick Bakeware Cookie Pan comes in a range of fun and vibrant colors that will add a pop of color to your kitchen. The sheet is made of heavy-gauge steel and has a nonstick surface that ensures effortless food release.
Best Value Cookware That Won't Break the Bank
You don’t have to break the bank to get high-quality cookware. The AmazonBasics Nonstick Carbon Steel Baking Sheet Set gives you two nonstick cookie sheets for an affordable price. The carbon steel construction ensures even heating, and the nonstick coating allows for easy food release and cleanup.
Cookware Sets That Will Cover All Your Cooking Needs
Getting a set of cookie sheets can be a great way to cover all your baking needs in one go. The Calphalon Nonstick Bakeware Set includes a large cookie sheet and two smaller ones, all made of heavy-gauge steel with a nonstick surface. The sheets are also oven safe up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit, giving you the versatility to bake a wide range of items.
Budget-Friendly Cookware That Performs Like a Pro
Just because you’re on a budget doesn’t mean you have to sacrifice quality. The Nordic Ware Aluminum Cookie Sheet Set is an affordable option that doesn’t compromise on performance. The set includes two sheets made of natural aluminum that heats up quickly and provides consistent results. The sheets are also easy to clean, making them a great value for your money.
Ceramic Coating Cookware That Will Last a Lifetime
If you’re looking for a durable option that will last you a lifetime, a ceramic coated cookie sheet is the way to go. The Farberware Purecook Ceramic Nonstick Baking Sheet is made of durable steel and has a ceramic coating that provides a nonstick surface that won’t chip or peel. The sheet is also dishwasher safe, making it easy to clean.
Editor's Pick: Cookware That We Can't Live Without
Our final pick is one that we truly can’t live without. The Wilton Perfect Results Premium Non-Stick Bakeware Large Cookie Pan has been our go-to choice for baking cookies for years. The large size makes it easy to bake a big batch of cookies at once, and the nonstick surface ensures easy release every time. The heavy-duty steel construction also ensures even heating and long-lasting durability.
With all these options to choose from, finding the perfect cookie sheet for your kitchen is no longer a daunting task. Whether you’re looking for affordability, durability, or a pop of color, there’s something for everyone on this list. Happy baking!