Skip to Content

Easy Turkey Nutter Butter Cookies

This year I’ll make sure there are plenty of Turkey Nutter Butter Cookies on hand so everyone can enjoy one. This recipe takes the deliciousness of Nutter Butter and turns it into a Thanksgiving turkey!

Nutter Butter Turkeys

Nutter Butter cookies are a classic American cookie enjoyed by people of all ages. This recipe takes the deliciousness of Nutter Butter and turns it into a Thanksgiving turkey!

Kids will love helping you make these adorable cookies, and they’ll be excited to gobble them up during the holiday feast.

When the dinner table is set with plenty of food and loved ones gather around, it’s time to be thankful for what we have.

This year I’ll make sure there are plenty of Turkey Nutter Butter Cookies on hand so everyone can enjoy one.

Turkey Nutter Butter Cookies

My grandkids love helping me assemble these delicious treats.

Get your baking supplies ready and let’s get started on these festive Nutter Butter Turkeys!

Turkey Nutter Butter Cookies

As an Amazon Associate, this post may contain affiliate links and I may receive a small commission at no additional cost to you. See my disclosure policy for more info.

Makes: 10
Prep: 20 Minutes

What is a Nutter Butter Cookie

A nutter butter cookie is a sandwich-style cookie made with two thin, graham cracker-like cookies with peanut butter filling in the middle.

These cookies are easy to make and perfect for parties or for satisfying a sweet tooth.

These crunchy, cookie-filled treats contain a sweet and creamy filling that will have your mouth watering before you even take one bite!

Nutter Butter Cookies Ingredients

  • Medium candy eyeballs – Choose your favorite medium candy eyeballs and get ready for a sweet treat! These tasty candies are perfect for decorating cakes, cupcakes, and cookies.
  • Orange M&M’s – M&M’s are one of the most popular candies in the world. Loved by people of all ages and come in a variety of colors.
  • 6 oz. chocolate candy melts – use your favorite brand.
  • Red candy melts – Take white candy melts and add red food coloring if you can’t find red.
  • Nutter butter cookies – They are an American favorite, and are popular all over the world.
  • For exact amounts, please see the recipe card below.

More Holiday Recipes

How to Make Nutter Butter Cookie Turkeys

Melt both the chocolate and the red candy melts as directed on the bag. Brand direction varies.

Turkey Nutter Butter Cookies

Dip half of the nutter butter into the chocolate candy melts. Place on parchment or freezer paper shiny side up.

Turkey Nutter Butter Cookies

Add the two eyes to the top of each nutter butter. Add the orange m&m’s for the nose area to all the nutter butter cookies. Let dry.

Finally, with a pastry brush add a good dab of red candy melts next to the nose. Let dry and serve!

Turkey Nutter Butter Cookies
Yield: 10

Nutter Butter Turkeys

Turkey Nutter Butter Cookies

This year I’ll make sure there are plenty of Turkey Nutter Butter Cookies on hand so everyone can enjoy one. This recipe takes the deliciousness of Nutter Butter and turns it into a Thanksgiving turkey!

Prep Time 20 minutes
Total Time 20 minutes

Ingredients

  • 20 medium candy eyeballs
  • 10 orange m&m’s
  • 6 oz. chocolate candy melts
  • 1/3 cup red candy melts
  • 10 nutter butters

Instructions

  1. Melt both the chocolate and the red candy melts as directed on the bag. Brand direction varies. Turkey Nutter Butter Cookies
  2. Dip half of the nutter butter into the chocolate candy melts. Place on parchment or freezer paper shiny side up. Turkey Nutter Butter Cookies
  3. Add the two eyes to the top of each nutter butter. Add the orange m&m’s for the nose area to all the nutter butter cookies. Let dry. Turkey Nutter Butter Cookies
  4. With a pastry brush add a good dab of red candy melts next to the nose. Let dry and serve! Turkey Nutter Butter Cookies

Nutrition Information:

Yield:

10

Serving Size:

1

Amount Per Serving: Calories: 362Total Fat: 18gSaturated Fat: 11gTrans Fat: 0gUnsaturated Fat: 5gCholesterol: 35mgSodium: 116mgCarbohydrates: 50gFiber: 4gSugar: 36gProtein: 3g

Nutrition may vary depending on the products used.

Did you make this recipe?

Please leave a comment on the blog or share a photo on Instagram

Turkey Nutter Butter Cookies

Be sure to pin it for later and follow us on Pinterest.

Turkey Nutter Butter Cookies

Skip to Recipe