Skip to Content

CARAMEL TURTLE ICE CREAM PIE RECIPE

Caramel Creams® Turtle Ice Cream Pie is a delicious, mouth watering pie made with Caramel Creams®, Chocolate, Pecans, no churn caramel ice cream all rolled into a chocolate crust and topped with whip cream. Is your mouth watering yet just thinking about it?

I have partnered with Goetze Candy to bring you this sponsored post. All opinions and recipe creation are my own and may differ from yours. 

CARAMEL TURTLE ICE CREAM PIE RECIPE 

CARAMEL CREAMS® TURTLE ICE CREAM PIE RECIPE

Yay, It’s National Pi Day! Ok, so maybe it’s technically not “Pie” day but in reality who needs a special day to celebrate Pie anyway? I know I don’t.

Anywho, we are here sharing a pie that I love to make for my family, Caramel Creams® Turtle Ice Cream Pie recipe. I bet you’re wondering why I call it Caramel Creams® (with an s on the end) instead of Caramel Cream, aren’t you?

The reason being is because it’s made with Goetze’s Caramel Creams® candy. You know, the company that also makes Cow Tales candy (my favorite candy ever!)

Caramel Creams® Turtle Ice Cream Pie is a delicious, mouth watering pie made with Caramel Creams®, Chocolate, Pecans, no churn caramel ice cream all rolled into a chocolate crust and topped with whip cream. Is your mouth watering yet just thinking about it? 

Did you know that Goetze’s Candy Company was started in 1895 but Goetze’s Caramel Creams®“Bulls-Eyes” were developed in 1918! That’s the year my dad was born so that means two great things happened that year.

Not only are they available in vanilla caramel today, but also strawberry, chocolate, apple and black licorice. Yum!

CARAMEL TURTLE ICE CREAM PIE RECIPE

 

Caramel Creams Pecan Turtle Ice Cream Pie Ingredients

  • Chocolate Crumb Cookie Crust (Pre-made or make your own)
  • 16 oz. Heavy Whipping Cream
  • 14 oz. can Sweetened Condensed Milk
  • 20 Original Vanilla Caramel Creams® unwrapped
  • 10 Chocolate Caramel Creams unwrapped
  • Container Cool Whip
  • 1 Cup chopped Walnuts
  • 1/2 cup semi sweet chocolate chips
  • 1 tsp. butter

CARAMEL TURTLE ICE CREAM PIE RECIPE

How to make Ice Cream Pie with Oreo Crust

Melt 15 Original Caramel Creams with 1/2 tsp. of butter in double broiler. I don’t have one so I use a glass pyrex bowl that fits in my pot perfectly.

Fill pot with enough water so the bowl floats. Or you can melt them in a glass bowl in the microwave if you prefer. 

Let caramel cool a bit before dumping into ice cream mixture. Spread Caramel into chocolate crumb cookie crust evenly and top with 1/2 cup chopped walnuts. 

CARAMEL TURTLE ICE CREAM PIE RECIPE

 

Caramel Creams® Turtle Ice Cream Pie is a delicious, mouth watering pie made with Caramel Creams®, Chocolate, Pecans, no churn caramel ice cream all rolled into a chocolate crust and topped with whip cream. Is your mouth watering yet just thinking about it? 

Place in fridge to firm up for about 15 minutes.

Melt 5 Chocolate Caramel Creams® in double broiler or microwave if you prefer with 1/8 tsp of butter. 

Caramel Creams® Turtle Ice Cream Pie is a delicious, mouth watering pie made with Caramel Creams®, Chocolate, Pecans, no churn caramel ice cream all rolled into a chocolate crust and topped with whip cream. Is your mouth watering yet just thinking about it? 

Pour Heavy Whipping cream into cold mixer bowl. Having the bowl chilled helps to make the heavy cream whip easier. Mix till stiff peaks form.

Caramel Creams® Turtle Ice Cream Pie is a delicious, mouth watering pie made with Caramel Creams®, Chocolate, Pecans, no churn caramel ice cream all rolled into a chocolate crust and topped with whip cream. Is your mouth watering yet just thinking about it? 

Once whip cream is done, gently fold in sweetened condensed milk and chocolate chips.

Caramel Creams® Turtle Ice Cream Pie is a delicious, mouth watering pie made with Caramel Creams®, Chocolate, Pecans, no churn caramel ice cream all rolled into a chocolate crust and topped with whip cream. Is your mouth watering yet just thinking about it? 

Let cool for a bit and then pour melted chocolate Caramel Creams and chocolate chips into mixture and swirl through.

Cover and place in freezer for at least 4 hours or overnight.

Caramel Creams® Turtle Ice Cream Pie is a delicious, mouth watering pie made with Caramel Creams®, Chocolate, Pecans, no churn caramel ice cream all rolled into a chocolate crust and topped with whip cream. Is your mouth watering yet just thinking about it? 

Top with Cool Whip.

Top with remaining 1/2 cup of chopped walnuts and chocolate chips.

Caramel Creams® Turtle Ice Cream Pie is a delicious, mouth watering pie made with Caramel Creams®, Chocolate, Pecans, no churn caramel ice cream all rolled into a chocolate crust and topped with whip cream. Is your mouth watering yet just thinking about it?   

Melt remaining 5 Original Vanilla Caramel Creams with 1/8 tsp of butter and drizzle over the top once cooled.

Melt remaining 5 Chocolate Caramel Creams with 1/8 tsp of butter and let cool a little bit before you drizzle over the top.

Caramel Creams® Turtle Ice Cream Pie is a delicious, mouth watering pie made with Caramel Creams®, Chocolate, Pecans, no churn caramel ice cream all rolled into a chocolate crust and topped with whip cream. Is your mouth watering yet just thinking about it? 

I placed the pie back in the freezer until we were ready to eat it, however, it’s ready to eat as soon as you finish decorating it. 

Run knife under hot water to cut easily and share with family and friends and Enjoy!

Caramel Creams® Turtle Ice Cream Pie is a delicious, mouth watering pie made with Caramel Creams®, Chocolate, Pecans, no churn caramel ice cream all rolled into a chocolate crust and topped with whip cream. Is your mouth watering yet just thinking about it? 

Caramel Creams® Turtle Ice Cream Pie is a delicious, mouth watering pie made with Caramel Creams®, Chocolate, Pecans, no churn caramel ice cream all rolled into a chocolate crust and topped with whip cream. Is your mouth watering yet just thinking about it? 

Caramel Creams® Turtle Ice Cream Pie is a delicious, mouth watering pie made with Caramel Creams®, Chocolate, Pecans, no churn caramel ice cream all rolled into a chocolate crust and topped with whip cream. Is your mouth watering yet just thinking about it? 

Now aren’t you glad you stopped by to check out this yummy, mouthwatering recipe? The Caramel Creams also make great additions to Easter baskets.

Find Caramel Creams at a store near you today! Connect with them on Facebook, Twitter, Pinterest and Instagram

Caramel Creams® Turtle Ice Cream Pie is a delicious, mouth watering pie made with Caramel Creams®, Chocolate, Pecans, no churn caramel ice cream all rolled into a chocolate crust and topped with whip cream. Is your mouth watering yet just thinking about it? 

 

Yield: 1

CARAMEL CREAMS® TURTLE ICE CREAM PIE RECIPE

TURTLE ICE CREAM PIE RECIPE

Caramel Creams® Turtle Ice Cream Pie is a delicious, mouth watering pie made with Caramel Creams®, Chocolate, Pecans, no churn caramel ice cream all rolled into a chocolate crust and topped with whip cream. Is your mouth watering yet just thinking about it? 

Prep Time 1 hour
Additional Time 4 hours
Total Time 5 hours

Ingredients

  • Chocolate Crumb Cookie Crust (Pre-made or make your own)
  • 16 oz. Heavy Whipping Cream
  • 14 oz. can Sweetened Condensed Milk
  • 20 Original Caramel Creams® unwrapped
  • 10 Chocolate Caramel Creams unwrapped
  • Container Cool Whip
  • 1 Cup chopped Walnuts
  • 1/2 cup semi sweet chocolate chips
  • 1 tsp. butter

Instructions

  1. Melt 10 Original Caramel Creams with 1/4 tsp. of butter in double broiler. I don't have one so I use a glass pyrex bowl that fits in my pot perfectly. Fill pot with enough water so the bowl floats. Or you can melt them in a glass bowl in the microwave if you prefer. 
  2. Spread Caramel into chocolate crumb cookie crust evenly and top with 1/2 cup chopped walnuts. 
  3. Place in fridge to firm up for about 15 minutes.
  4. Melt 5 Chocolate Caramel Creams in double broiler or microwave if you prefer with 1/8 tsp of butter. 
  5. Pour Heavy Whipping cream into cold mixer bowl. Having the bowl chilled helps to make the heavy cream whip easier. Mix till stiff peaks form.
  6. Once whip cream is done, gently fold in sweetened condensed milk. 
  7. Once cooled pour melted chocolate Caramel Creams and chocolate chips into mixture and swirl through.
  8. Place in freezer for at least 4 hours or overnight.
  9. Top with Cool Whip.
  10. Top with remaining 1/2 cup of chopped walnuts.  
  11. Melt remaining 10 Original Caramel Creams with 1/2 tsp of butter and drizzle over the top once cooled.
  12. Melt remaining 5 Chocolate Caramel Creams with 1/8 tsp of butter, let cool and drizzle over the top.
  13. Share with family and friends and Enjoy!

Nutrition Information:

Yield:

8

Serving Size:

1/8

Amount Per Serving: Calories: 889Total Fat: 47gSaturated Fat: 24gTrans Fat: 1gUnsaturated Fat: 20gCholesterol: 105mgSodium: 474mgCarbohydrates: 115gFiber: 2gSugar: 111gProtein: 12g

Nutrition may vary depending on the products used.

Did you make this recipe?

Please leave a comment on the blog or share a photo on Instagram

Caramel Creams® Turtle Ice Cream Pie is a delicious, mouth watering pie made with Caramel Creams®, Chocolate, Pecans, no churn caramel ice cream all rolled into a chocolate crust and topped with whip cream. Is your mouth watering yet just thinking about it? 

 

Don’t forget to pin it for later and follow us on Pinterest

 

Caramel Creams® Turtle Ice Cream Pie is a delicious, mouth watering pie made with Caramel Creams®, Chocolate, Pecans, no churn caramel ice cream all rolled into a chocolate crust and topped with whip cream. Is your mouth watering yet just thinking about it? 

 

Laurie Nykaza

Wednesday 20th of March 2019

I've never tried making one of these before for the family to enjoy but now with this recipe im going to give it a try, Love the mix of flavors used too

Lyndsey Rullman

Wednesday 20th of March 2019

Oh man!!! I would probably eat the whole thing in 3 days...by myself! I love turtles!

Jared Ruman

Tuesday 19th of March 2019

I want to marry this pie. Seriously. I would get down on one knee and ask this pie to marry me.

Sara Tarver

Tuesday 19th of March 2019

Wow this pie looks delicious! I would love to try it!

kathy pease

Tuesday 19th of March 2019

Omg this looks so good. My husband would polish this off in one day.

Skip to Recipe